• Advertisement

So what's the difference between a prepper and survivalist?

General discussion board for ANTS members

Moderator: founderant

So what's the difference between a prepper and survivalist?

Postby founderant » Sun Feb 24, 2013 4:04 pm

So what's the difference between a prepper and survivalist?

For me, a survivalist does not need stored supplies to survive and a prepper does.
Americans Networking To Survive
http://www.americansnetworkingtosurvive.org/
User avatar
founderant
A.N.T.S. Founder
A.N.T.S. Founder
 
Posts: 2873
Images: 2
Joined: Wed Feb 03, 2010 7:19 pm
Location: NC
Karma: 41

Re: So what's the difference between a prepper and survivali

Postby RudytheGreat » Sun Feb 24, 2013 4:10 pm

Sounds good to me. I'm 70 and do not wish to live under a tree branch and eat snails. I am going to Bug In and eat my canned Spam, and I would shoot anyone who tries to take my Spam away. You can be shot eating snails or Spam, when the end comes, it comes.
Rudy hates what this country has turned into!
User avatar
RudytheGreat
Washington Preppers Network
Washington Preppers Network
 
Posts: 7
Joined: Sat Jan 21, 2012 9:47 pm
Location: Auburn, WA
Karma: 0

Re: So what's the difference between a prepper and survivali

Postby founderant » Sun Feb 24, 2013 4:24 pm

Snails and spam, I think you might have something there. :D
Americans Networking To Survive
http://www.americansnetworkingtosurvive.org/
User avatar
founderant
A.N.T.S. Founder
A.N.T.S. Founder
 
Posts: 2873
Images: 2
Joined: Wed Feb 03, 2010 7:19 pm
Location: NC
Karma: 41

Re: So what's the difference between a prepper and survivali

Postby Anarchy » Sun Feb 24, 2013 5:21 pm

RudytheGreat wrote:Sounds good to me. I'm 70 and do not wish to live under a tree branch and eat snails. I am going to Bug In and eat my canned Spam, and I would shot anyone who tries to take my Spam away. You can be shot eating snails or Spam, when the end comes, it comes.


Ive eatten stuff that would make a pig puke SPAM sounds great if i go passing by i''ll have the Bread and Mustard :clap: dont shoot me :surrender: Oooo by the way 70 is the new 40 dont cha know that.... :thumbsup:
User avatar
Anarchy
 
Posts: 150
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2013 6:06 pm
Location: Central Maine right smack behind enemy lines...
Karma: 0

Re: So what's the difference between a prepper and survivali

Postby Tom Bergstrand » Sun Feb 24, 2013 5:29 pm

From what I see on some forums survivalists are a bit more aggressive. One problem that I see with that is that they will have to go out and take food which necessitates leaving their AO. IMHO it is easier to defend than to assault. The German Army learned that at Stalingrad. They were subjected to the elements while the inhabitants sat in "somewhat" better conditions. When defending you have the benefit of knowing the terrain while they might not. We can sneak out in 2 or 3 man teams (flashback) and accomplish stuff that they are not expecting. We can store more than they can carry soooo after several days we sleep in shifts and eat while they are probably not so blessed. Anyone that has ever BTDT remembers that you sacrificed carrying food for carrying ammo. If you can capture food .... good. If you can't .... not good. After a couple of days the hunger definitely gets your attention. I would think that as a prepper I am planning to survive. Therefore a survivalist should also prep. Many on the internet don't seem to follow that logic. Time will tell.
Tom in Kingman Arizona
Oath Keeper #005181
Kingman Lodge #22 F&AM Kingman Arizona
U.S. Paratrooper
User avatar
Tom Bergstrand
Arizona Preppers Network
Arizona Preppers Network
 
Posts: 601
Joined: Sun Jan 16, 2011 12:44 am
Location: Kingman AZ
Karma: 31

Re: So what's the difference between a prepper and survivali

Postby Blackthorn-USA » Sun Feb 24, 2013 6:18 pm

The main difference I see is that it gives Preppers someone to feel superior too. Yeah yeah, hear me out. Before anyone had heard of a prepper there were survivalists who thought that being prepared for disaster whether it was nuclear war, government take over, NWO, EMP or whatever seemed to be a prudent course of action. Sure there were a few kooks just like there are a few kooks in prepper circles now. But the survivalists were seen as a threat because they had evil black scary guns, much like a lot of preppers do now… See a trend?

So in the 90’s the media did everything thing they could to associate survivalists with anything they thought the public deemed evil. Back in the good old days of the original ’94 gun ban, militias, domestic terrorism was brand new and the media was quite successful in demonizing the survivalists.

So years later the term prepper shows up as some kind of non-kooky, warm-fuzzy way to describe people who want to prepare for disaster by becoming more self reliant and stocking a few extra supplies. This was nice and politically correct for a little while until the media discovered that OMG preppers have guns too! And they’re hoarding food, why I’ll bet some of them even believe in God and homeschool their kids!

The difference between Preppers and Survivalists is about 20 years. That’s it. I hear preppers all to often talking about “well it's not like we're crazy survivalists”. Well the media is coming for you preppers now. I think the sooner everyone understands that we all are preparing to survive and stop buying the social warfare line that somehow one group is superior to the other the better off we’ll all be.

Regardless of what we call ourselves, the media will demonize us and the general public will fear us. How about we agree that intelligent, self-reliant people prepare to survive regardless of what they may be called and concentrate on working together?

IMHO, YMMV,ETC
Blackthorn-USA
Outdoor Adventure School
User avatar
Blackthorn-USA
APN Sponsor Member
APN Sponsor Member
 
Posts: 156
Joined: Sun Apr 29, 2012 6:54 pm
Location: Central Kansas
Karma: 17

Re: So what's the difference between a prepper and survivali

Postby TimWhite » Sun Feb 24, 2013 7:56 pm

Blackthorn-USA wrote:The main difference I see is that it gives Preppers someone to feel superior too. Yeah yeah, hear me out. Before anyone had heard of a prepper there were survivalists who thought that being prepared for disaster whether it was nuclear war, government take over, NWO, EMP or whatever seemed to be a prudent course of action. Sure there were a few kooks just like there are a few kooks in prepper circles now. But the survivalists were seen as a threat because they had evil black scary guns, much like a lot of preppers do now… See a trend?

So in the 90’s the media did everything thing they could to associate survivalists with anything they thought the public deemed evil. Back in the good old days of the original ’94 gun ban, militias, domestic terrorism was brand new and the media was quite successful in demonizing the survivalists.

So years later the term prepper shows up as some kind of non-kooky, warm-fuzzy way to describe people who want to prepare for disaster by becoming more self reliant and stocking a few extra supplies. This was nice and politically correct for a little while until the media discovered that OMG preppers have guns too! And they’re hoarding food, why I’ll bet some of them even believe in God and homeschool their kids!

The difference between Preppers and Survivalists is about 20 years. That’s it. I hear preppers all to often talking about “well it's not like we're crazy survivalists”. Well the media is coming for you preppers now. I think the sooner everyone understands that we all are preparing to survive and stop buying the social warfare line that somehow one group is superior to the other the better off we’ll all be.

Regardless of what we call ourselves, the media will demonize us and the general public will fear us. How about we agree that intelligent, self-reliant people prepare to survive regardless of what they may be called and concentrate on working together?

IMHO, YMMV,ETC



I haven't decided if I'm a survialrepper or a prepurlist :huh: :unsure:
"We can have no '50-50' allegiance in this country. Either a man is an American and nothing else, or he is not an American at all."
Theodore Roosevelt

"Pride and arrogance are a lethal combination and have brought about the downfall of many powerful men". Charlie Daniels
User avatar
TimWhite
Illinois Preppers Network
Illinois Preppers Network
 
Posts: 1257
Images: 0
Joined: Sat Dec 03, 2011 10:46 am
Location: East Central Illinois
Karma: 29

Re: So what's the difference between a prepper and survivali

Postby sageprice » Sun Feb 24, 2013 8:08 pm

Those who do not prep normally die. Therefore, if you prep you are a survivalist.
User avatar
sageprice
Maryland Preppers Network
Maryland Preppers Network
 
Posts: 734
Images: 0
Joined: Tue May 29, 2012 7:22 pm
Location: Northern AA county Maryland
Karma: 47

Re: So what's the difference between a prepper and survivali

Postby Colombo » Sun Feb 24, 2013 9:30 pm

founderant wrote:So what's the difference between a prepper and survivalist?

For me, a survivalist does not need stored supplies to survive and a prepper does.


No way I can let that kind of obama style divisive statement slide.

Long before there were "preppers" survivalists were doing some of the hard work with a new concept, thinking about and preparing as well as catching hell from the masses who just 15 years earlier thought fallout shelters and civil defense were cool. From what I've seen the percentage of survivalist who actually have tried out the ideas were much higher than the percentages of preppers of whom more than a few smell like fair weather keyboard commandos. Military manuals and government publications mail ordered and waited for were read, tried and talked about (my first order included a book on beekeeping). We went out and "camped" in winter in upstate NY. We learned land nav. We built fires and shelters, bunkers, collected intel, some worked out religiously, trained in armed and unarmed (a lot of us were expecting commies after the nukes)...
...and yes we shot the hell out of our weapons and were considered odd. Regroup, rebuild, revenge, the three Rs.

Tom Bergstrand wrote:From what I see on some forums survivalists are a bit more aggressive. One problem that I see with that is that they will have to go out and take food which necessitates leaving their AO. IMHO it is easier to defend than to assault. The German Army learned that at Stalingrad.

Like your post, a couple of points though...
That some idiots out there are calling themselves survivalist AND considering theft because they don't stock food doesn't make it so. I know what old civil defense crackers, hard candy, and c-rats as well as spam and other canned goods taste like, some heated on an old coleman stove thanks to old style real surplus stores. As for the thought that defending is easier, be very careful with thinking like that and look to expand your knowledge base (this is a friendly suggestion not an attack) tactical and strategic are very different animals. Honest men have to work for a living, they don't always get to choose the place or time. In a bad situation attrition is a powerful ally and a devastating enemy.
cruor et ferrum cinis et lemures
User avatar
Colombo
 
Posts: 32
Joined: Sat Oct 16, 2010 10:50 am
Karma: 0

Re: So what's the difference between a prepper and survivali

Postby founderant » Sun Feb 24, 2013 10:27 pm

What's divisive about my statement? When I think of a survivalist, I think of someone that can walk into the woods with nothing and survive. Most preppers can not do that in my opinion. If they can, then they are a survivalist. Just my opinion, it is not meant to divide, but there is a difference.
Americans Networking To Survive
http://www.americansnetworkingtosurvive.org/
User avatar
founderant
A.N.T.S. Founder
A.N.T.S. Founder
 
Posts: 2873
Images: 2
Joined: Wed Feb 03, 2010 7:19 pm
Location: NC
Karma: 41

Re: So what's the difference between a prepper and survivali

Postby contrarian » Sun Feb 24, 2013 11:10 pm

Back in the day I claimed the label survivalist and I never had any desire to live in the woods. I did, and do, have a desire to survive; a drive to survive even. Nothing has changed but the label.
Prepping -- prudence in action
I prep not panic.
No, you may not quote me or my posts either for any book, for any reason without my express written permission.
contrarian
Colorado Preppers Network
Colorado Preppers Network
 
Posts: 1044
Joined: Fri Aug 05, 2011 9:54 pm
Karma: 11

Re: So what's the difference between a prepper and survivali

Postby Colombo » Wed Feb 27, 2013 2:05 am

founderant wrote:What's divisive about my statement? When I think of a survivalist, I think of someone that can walk into the woods with nothing and survive. Most preppers can not do that in my opinion. If they can, then they are a survivalist. Just my opinion, it is not meant to divide, but there is a difference.


Simple, the skill sets needed are so closely related they should completely cross over. Limit or focus on just survival or just prepping as you've defined them and you reduce your capacity to respond and quite possibly live thru what at best is unpredictable.
Additionally your making possible targets out of allies who will be picked off by those who would like nothing better than a repeat of the ignorance and smug superiority shown by many gun owners when they let the hughes amendment get tacked onto the McClure-Volkmer act without a whimper. I remember nra leaders and members stating that nobody needs that kind of weapon. Want a simpler and yet more extreme example that started with two totally unrelated groups like law abiding citizens and drug dealers? How well has letting law enforcement and the government cut away at the bill of rights worked for us? I remember the arguments that loosening search and seizure laws would only be used against drug dealers, been thru an airport security check lately? Now add government suspected/possible terrorist to the mix and consider where that may lead. Any weakness will be exploited.

Identify and draw distinctions within a small community and your showing our weak points to those who will subdue us and gaining nothing in the process but possible resentment down the road from some in our very own community, the point at which we need as many friends as possible.
cruor et ferrum cinis et lemures
User avatar
Colombo
 
Posts: 32
Joined: Sat Oct 16, 2010 10:50 am
Karma: 0

Re: So what's the difference between a prepper and survivali

Postby Lynda » Wed Feb 27, 2013 5:20 am

sageprice wrote:Those who do not prep normally die. Therefore, if you prep you are a survivalist.



That works for me.
THINK......It's not illegal yet.

I Am Responsible For What I Say. I Am Not Responsible For What You Understand.
User avatar
Lynda
Massachusetts Preppers Network
Massachusetts Preppers Network
 
Posts: 6534
Images: 6
Joined: Mon Jun 07, 2010 5:30 pm

Re: So what's the difference between a prepper and survivali

Postby theoutback » Wed Feb 27, 2013 6:16 am

founderant wrote:What's divisive about my statement? When I think of a survivalist, I think of someone that can walk into the woods with nothing and survive. Most preppers can not do that in my opinion. If they can, then they are a survivalist. Just my opinion, it is not meant to divide, but there is a difference.


Perfectly fine statement imo. :thumbup:
User avatar
theoutback
 
Posts: 832
Joined: Thu Apr 05, 2012 6:38 pm
Location: Vermont
Karma: 65

Re: So what's the difference between a prepper and survivali

Postby Das Sheep » Wed Feb 27, 2013 6:54 am

Most survivalists still use supplies, and few could last an entire year with no stored food and no planted food.

Even when you go a bushcrafting you still typically bring some food, even if its just to supplement what you normally catch and kill, or find.

I think its the bullets to beans ratio that makes a prepper or survivalist.
Das Sheep
Florida Preppers Network
Florida Preppers Network
 
Posts: 3224
Images: 21
Joined: Fri Jul 27, 2012 8:27 pm
Location: North East Florida
Karma: 125

Next

Return to A.N.T.S.

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest


Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Sign up for the APN Email Newsletter - Enter your e-mail address below


  Links and Resources
  -Links
  -Podcasts
  -Pioneer Living
  -Free Ebooks








State Networks
Use the scroll bar below to find out what's going on in your state.
Alabama
Blog    Forum

Alaska
Blog    Forum

Arizona
Blog    Forum

Arkansas
Blog    Forum

California
Blog    Forum

Colorado
Blog    Forum

Connecticut
Blog    Forum

Delaware
Blog    Forum

Florida
Blog    Forum

Georgia
Blog    Forum

Hawaii
Blog    Forum

Idaho
Blog    Forum

Illinois
Blog    Forum

Indiana
Blog    Forum

Iowa
Blog    Forum

Kansas
Blog    Forum

Kentucky
Blog    Forum

Louisiana
Blog    Forum

Maine
Blog    Forum

Maryland
Blog    Forum

Massachusetts
Blog    Forum

Michigan
Blog    Forum

Minnesota
Blog    Forum

Mississippi
Blog    Forum

Missouri
Blog    Forum

Montana
Blog    Forum

Nebraska
Blog    Forum

Nevada
Blog    Forum

New Hampshire
Blog    Forum

New Jersey
Blog    Forum

New Mexico
Blog    Forum

New York
Blog    Forum

North Carolina
Blog    Forum

North Dakota
Blog    Forum

Ohio
Blog    Forum

Oklahoma
Blog    Forum

Oregon
Blog    Forum

Pennsylvania
Blog    Forum

Rhode Island
Blog    Forum

South Carolina
Blog    Forum

South Dakota
Blog    Forum

Tennessee
Blog    Forum

Texas
Blog    Forum

Utah
Blog    Forum

Vermont
Blog    Forum

Virginia
Blog    Forum

Washington
Blog    Forum

West Virginia
Blog    Forum

Wisconsin
Blog    Forum

Wyoming
Blog    Forum


Trusted Sponsors


Copyright
For Notices of Copyright infringement and to contact our DMCA Agent please follow the link below:
Copyright Policy

For terms of use, rules, and policies please read our Disclaimer